The Art Historian is a funny bird. Something of a rare species, no one is entirely sure what exactly it is that an Art Historian does during and after the schooling process. Art Historians themselves are not always sure. In a sprawling discipline that prides itself on its interdisciplinarity, such ambivalence can often render conversation difficult, or at least unpredictable.
Paradoxically, both the cause and the escape of such uncomfortable exchanges a can be traced to a single source: a German Name.
The Germans, it seems, have studied pretty much everything. They’re also pretty good about writing down everything they’ve studied. Better still, they disagree all the time with each other, which means more thinking and more writing. Whole forests have been felled to accomodate the machinations of the German Mind. Germans also seem to float fairly freely between disciplines, doing exotic things like talk about photography, memory, and national identity all in one essay. German Names have a tendency to pop up when you least expect them. You’ll be talking about 1930s abstraction and then, out of nowhere, Brecht shows up. In the middle of Baroque poetic portraiture, Benjamin makes an appearance. Adorno drops in on discussions of jazz music. If you’re not careful, Arendt will pop up in the middle of a banal landscape painting.
Operating in their special world of elaborate cross-pollinations, Art Historians like German Names. They make us feel like we belong to disciplines like History and Literature that normal people know about. I’m fairly certain that if I ever get my PhD, I will be handed a small, pocket-size encyclopedia of German Names that I will henceforth be expected to utilize in case a conversation is accidentally becoming too accessible.
On the other hand, no one, really, has read all the German Names. And it is this sheer volume that will extricate you from the most dire of academically-overwrought conversations. “Oh,” you could say, “I’m not sure if you’re familiar with the writings of Warheimsteiner.* He may be of help to you since he considers the aesthetic power of small woodland creatures and the socio-environmental implications thereof.” And then, as the Art Historian rifles through her mental file of German Names, you can excuse yourself for a much-needed refill of the wine glass.
That said, taking Noel’s last name for my own may have been the greatest professional move of my life. Perhaps one day I, too, can be a German Name.
* Lebenmier, Kaufenkop, Hammsteil, Schuebenhauer, etc. may also be substituted.